About Us
The Turtle Lake Tap and Grill property has been a landmark of the Turtle Lake community for more than 140 years. Our latest chapter began when Jeff and Ann Hufford set out to bring new life to this historic space and restore the sense of community around the lake they’ve called home for over 20 years.
To make that vision a reality, they formed a private equity company and invited neighbors within the subdivision to join them. Eight lake families invested in the project, helping transform a shared dream into a true community effort. The company closed on the property on December 20, 2019, and we proudly opened our doors in May 2020.
Since opening, we’ve navigated unprecedented challenges—from COVID-19 to record inflation—and we’re grateful for the incredible support from our customers and community. Together, we’re building Turtle Lake Tap and Grill into a premier lakefront dining destination and a welcoming gathering place for all.
We hope you enjoy your time at our little slice of Midwest heaven.
Partners & Contributors
Nick and Alexis Acker • John and Jeanne Schehl • Gerry and Kathleen Burns • Tracy Porter • Liz and Kris Gronert • Quin and Donnelle Studer • Jeff and Caroline Hefty • Candace and Scott Nowicki • Paul and Tina Jones • Liz and Charlie Morand • Ryan and Tracy Coleman • Samantha and Chad Visger • Pat McIntyre • Donnie Trottier
What People Are Saying
“The burger I had was cooked perfectly. I also had the stuffed jalapeños and they were great! Great drink selection and local beers on tap. Outdoor seating options, and when you are done, there are chairs by the water you can use. Just ask before you head down as you need to switch to a plastic container. No glass off the deck area.”
— Anthony Z., Google Review
“A hidden gem! We stumbled upon this place and it was worth the wait. The cheese curds were delicious, my chicken sandwich was perfectly cooked. The little ones enjoyed their chocolate milk and meals but the big hit was the service. The staff were great. Super nice to the kids and patient too. The only downside was I needed to change my 2-month-old’s diaper and when I got into the bathroom there was nowhere to do it so I had to go out to my car instead. Other than that I would go back to eat here and recommend it to others. The view of the lake was a nice bonus and I bet it's even better in the summer.”
— Lisa C., Google Review
“Fish fry - Old Fashioned - Sunsets! Great Great service and great fish fry! The view of the lake is awesome with chairs on the beach were so relaxing to watch the sun go down. The old fashioned was also sooo good!! We will be back!!!.”
— Kristine N., Google Review
“Food was great, the view was perfect… First time there; we will be back. We would like to mention that our lights were left on and we could not start our car, and the staff took the time to come help jump the car and stayed with us until we figured it out. What a great group. Special thank you to Bry, Nole, Andrew, and Nakita.. that was very kind of you to stay with us and help.”
— Debbie M., Google Review
“The staff was very nice and the food great. It is a great family atmosphere. They had a nice hot chocolate bar to enjoy while resting after ice skating.”
— Eric F., Google Review
We found the place quite by chance. We were looking for someplace to go after hiking in Carver Roehl Park. We found it on the map and are very happy we did. Located on the shore of Turtle Lake it has great outdoor seating overlooking the lake. I had the TL Spicy Chicken sandwich was excellent. My wife had the Chicken Quesadilla which was also excellent. We also had a Mai Ti and Tipsy Turtle for drinks. The staff was very friendly and helpful.
— David C., Google Review
CURRENT HOURS OF OPERATION*:
Thursday: 4:00pm - 9:00pm
Friday: 11:00am - 11:00pm
Saturday: 11:00am - 11:00pm
Sunday: 11:00am - 9:00pm
*Please check our Special Events tab for Holiday Hours as open and close time may differ.